American Media Distorts Venezuelan Protests

Image Wikimedia Commons

Image Wikimedia Commons

For the last several weeks, much of the American media has been reporting on the anti-government protests occurring in the streets of Venezuela. Many major outlets have depicted Venezuela as being in the midst of a Ukrainian-style revolution. Stories of violent government crackdowns and photos of Venezuelans taking to the streets in droves to topple their democratically elected president Nicolás Maduro have saturated the media, but do those photos and stories represent the full story? Or has the American media been distorting the situation in Venezuela?

On February 20, the New York Times reported that the only media outlet that regularly broadcasted the voices of the opposition was sold last year and since then their news coverage has been softened. The Committee to Protect Journalists took it a step further by writing that nearly all the Venezuelan media has been ignoring the protests because it is all controlled by or allied with the Maduro government.

Whether or not the media has equal representations of both sides is critical. In an effort to paint President Nicolas Maduro as a dictator, opposition leader Leopold Lopez alleged that there was no longer any free media for government critics to express themselves. The American media quickly picked this up as fact without doing any research.

A quick look at the facts quickly leads to the realization that Leopold’s statements are patently false. The biggest broadcasting station Venevisión—which has 35 percent of the news-watching audience during key newsworthy events—actually does broadcast opposition voices including Tomàs Gaunipa, the leader of the Primero Justica (First Justice) opposition party, and María Corina Machado, a prominent hardline opposition leader.

The poor coverage of the Venezuelan protests extends beyond reporting false statements regarding the Venezuelan media. In its portrayal of the protests the American media is reporting that the protests are nationwide. The Latin Post reports that the protests are disrupting life in Venezuela; however, an on-the-ground report from The Guardian reveals that for much of Caracas, life is operating as normal, save for the few wealthy enclaves of the city. It appears that the anti-government protests are being conducted by wealthier, right-wing Venezuelans.

The Caracas Chronicles wrote on February 20 of a violent crackdown against protesters in Venezuela. The piece even went viral, garnering international attention from all sides of the political spectrum. The article painted a dark picture of state-sanctioned murders. In reality, more victims have been killed at the hands of protesters, than at the hands security officials.

The above observations are not meant to discredit any grievances of the Venezuelans or to gloss over the deaths and injuries that have occurred. Nor are they an attempt to explain the reasoning behind the protests. However, the misinformation being spread by the media is distorting the real story in Venezuela. Before the United States or the average citizen can endorse or condemn the protests currently happening in Venezuela, a balanced and truthful picture of the situation must be painted.

Nathalie Baptiste is a Haitian-American contributor to Foreign Policy In Focus who lives in the Washington, D.C. area. She holds a BA and MA in International Studies and writes about Latin America and the Caribbean. You can follow her on Twitter at @nhbaptiste

  • Contig

    The “on-the-ground report from The Guardian” that you mention is Mark Weisbrot. In 2009, Weisbrot and Tariq Ali wrote the screenplay for the Oliver Stone’s South of the border, a “documentary” paid by former Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez, made to portray the “wonders” of the so called “21th century revolution”. Since then, Mark Weisbrot is paid by the venezuelan goverment to write in their favour at international media, including “The Guardian”

  • Contig

    The “on-the-ground report from The Guardian ” is actually wrote by Mark Weisbrot, who in 2009 co-wrote the scriptplay for the “documentary” South of the border, directed by Oliver Stone and paid by former president Hugo Chavez, to praise the “bolivarian revolution”. Since them, the venezuelan goverment pays to Weisbrot to portray the wonders of the bolivarian revolution on international media.