It’s Not Only the U.S. That Israel Resents

Many Israeli politicians admire Russian President Vladimir Putin. (Image: Donkey Hotey / Flickr Commons)

Many Israeli politicians admire Russian President Vladimir Putin. (Image: Donkey Hotey / Flickr Commons)

Israel is becoming more and more of an authoritarian state, in the mold of Russia or China. In an article in the London Review of Books titled Israel’s Putinisation, Adam Shatz writes:

Israeli politicians have made no secret of their admiration for Putin, a tough, ruthless leader whose resolve – and preference for military solutions – stands in sharp contrast to the caution and indecision of Barack Obama. Putin is also, in Israeli eyes, refreshingly indifferent to human rights. As relations with the Obama administration have cooled … Israel has increasingly turned to Russia, as well as to China, from which it now imports more than it does from the US.

… Writing in 2003, at a time of high Euro-optimism, Tony Judt described Israel as a ‘characteristically late 19th-century separatist project’ in ‘a world that has moved on, a world of individual rights, open frontiers and international law … Israel, in short, is an anachronism.’ Today, it is Judt’s cheerfully Hegelian description of ‘a world that has moved on’ that seems out of step with the neo-tribal spirit of the times. Israel does not seem like such an outlier in a world reshaped by the drive towards ethnic and religious separatism, the militarised policing of frontiers, and the emergence of authoritarian populist governments.

In keeping with the increasing authoritarianism, Shatz points out something curious about Israel which you may not have heard. (I know I hadn’t.)

There has always been a deep strain of contempt in Zionism for the Yiddish-speaking Jews of Eastern Europe, who lacked the will, or the muscle, to defend themselves against anti-Semitic violence. The veneration of the state and the worship of force that are the pillars of Jewish identity in Israel, as much as Judaism itself, grew out of an effort to wash away [this] shame. … But the cult of state and army was always tempered … by a nostalgic attachment to liberal European values, an attachment that was particularly strong among Jews of German origin. … But their power, their numbers and their cultural authority have declined over the years: they are an old elite, and viewed with the disdain and resentment that old elites tend to provoke. … It is no wonder that, as Asher Schechter recently observed in Haaretz, ‘Israel is increasingly turning its back on Europe.’

  • BuberZionist

    The headline does not match the article. Who says Israel resents the US? This article makes no such claim.

    • Michael Holloway

      Israelis complains about the US, in much the same way as they complain and make paranoid conspiracy theories about everything else. It becomes difficult to determine exactly what they believe, but on the whole Israel is not about to “turn it’s back” on either the US or Europe.

  • Dru Ultrason

    FREE PALESTINE

  • Michael Holloway

    Americans can be forgiven for not understanding the function and necessity of ethnic homelands, but Europeans have no such claim to honest ignorance. Just because many of them now want to emulate America, without quite realizing what they’re doing, and adopt aspirations of becoming ethnically diverse at some point in the future, doesn’t wipe out the fact that nations representing ethnic homelands is the rule rather than the exception across most of the globe.

  • Nick

    >>Shatz points out something curious about Israel which you may not have heard. (I know I hadn’t.)

    >>There has always been a deep strain of contempt in Zionism for the Yiddish-speaking Jews of Eastern Europe, who lacked the will, or the muscle, to defend themselves against anti-Semitic violence.

    That’s not news – Zionists have always hated the Jews.

  • Harry

    Europe turned its back on Israel a long time ago. It’s about time Israel got to doing the same.