Preventing the Next Battle of Okinawa

postcard-okinawa-henoko-base-protests-futenmaDuring the Battle of Okinawa, thousands of civilians were caught in the crossfire as U.S. and Japanese troops waged one of the final—and bloodiest—fights of World War II. The combat lasted for more than three months, devastated the south and center of the island, and forced starving refugees to flee to the relative safety of the north. There, they turned to the place that had always sustained them during difficult times: the sea.

One of the areas whose seaweed, fish, and shellfish provided sustenance for traumatized survivors was Cape Henoko. Located on the northeast shore of Okinawa, Henoko is still held in special esteem by many elderly Okinawans who remember the way its bounty supported them.

Home to mangrove forests, sea turtles, and a large colony of endangered blue coral, it remains one of the environmentally richest areas in Japan. In 2009 alone, researchers from the World Wildlife Fund discovered 36 new species of crustaceans there. For many people, what makes the place so unique is the dugong—a relative of the Florida manatee that was once revered as a mythical animal by Okinawans—whose tell-tale grazing trenches have been spotted throughout the area.

For decades, this abundance of nature has existed uneasily alongside a sprawling U.S. marine base, Camp Schwab. During the 1960s, the installation housed nuclear warheads, and U.S. veterans claim that Agent Orange was stored there in large quantities. Indeed, run-off from the defoliant has been blamed for wiping out the area’s seaweed farms.

But now Henoko faces a threat even more serious than these weapons of mass destruction: the construction of a new U.S. military base. If built, the installation will bury between 120 and 160 hectares of the bay, wiping out the dugongs’ pastures, destroying swaths of coral, and disrupting the currents that make the bay and the surrounding seas so alive. Just as harmful is the likely extinction of the local fishing trade, the constant roar of low-flying aircraft, and the 24-7 threat of accidents.

Standing athwart the Tide

Although the Pentagon first spelled out plans for a new base in Henoko in the 1960s at the height of the Cold War, its most recent incarnation dates to the mid-1990s. Following the gang-rape of an Okinawan school girl by U.S. service members, Tokyo and Washington attempted to placate Okinawans’ rage with a promise to shut the Futenma Marine Corps base, a widely despised installation in the urban heart of the island.

But this closure would come at a price—before Futenma was returned to civilian usage, Washington demanded that a replacement facility be found. The Pentagon saw this as its chance finally to get the Henoko base it had been wanting for 40 years. It a was a particularly sweet deal given the fact that the cost of the base’s construction— currently estimated at $2 billion—would be entirely financed by Japanese taxpayers.

In preparation for the destruction of Henoko, the Japanese government began a survey of the area in April 2004. The response of Okinawans and their supporters was immediate.

Over the next 18 months, 60,000 people—many of them old enough to recall firsthand how the bay’s bounty had saved them during World War II—embarked upon a three-front campaign of civil disobedience. On the land, they lay down in front of bulldozers. When the government attempted to bypass them by heading out to sea, demonstrators took to canoes. Beneath the waves, some protesters donned scuba tanks and confronted government divers. Faced with such overwhelming opposition, the Japanese government backed down in September 2005.

But it hasn’t given up.

Since then, both Tokyo and Washington have persisted with the plan, refusing to close the dangerous Futenma base until the new Henoko facility is built. Meanwhile, the Japanese government has poured sweeteners into the island amounting to $3 billion a year, which has done very little to curb poverty in the country’s poorest prefecture.

Having completed its seriously flawed environmental assessments (which unsurprisingly claim that the environmental impact of decimating Henoko would be minimal), now all Tokyo needs is one final legal requirement: the approval of Okinawa’s governor, Hirokazu Nakaima.

The 73-year old politician is in a difficult position.

Nakaima is a member of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, but he has staunchly refused to support the Henoko base plan—making him a renegade and outcast in his own party. Tokyo has a variety of underhand techniques with which it can pressure him to sign: it might threaten to withhold funds set aside for Okinawa or even sue the governor as it did Masahide Ota, the former governor who refused to renew land leases for U.S. bases in 1996.

Public opposition to the Henoko Base is adamant—a 2012 newspaper poll found that 90 percent of Okinawans oppose the plan, and the leaders of all 41 of the island’s municipalities are also against it.

Postcard Solidarity

Out of this determination, a citizens’ movement has sprung up to fortify the will of the governor. Called the “Postcard campaign to save Henoko and Oura Bay,” hundreds of people from all over Japan and overseas have begun inundating the governor’s office with messages of solidarity.

Masami Kawamura, the organizer of the campaign, says that its goal is simple. “We need to show the governor our support,” he said. “We want him to stand firm and protect Oura Bay for future generations.”

School children have sent hand-drawn cards decorated with manga-cute dugongs. Parents have sent pictures of their own children urging the governor to think about his legacy. Postcards have poured in from overseas.

The designs might be diverse, but the message is united: Henoko is one of the world’s treasures and it needs to be protected—not buried beneath millions of tons of concrete.

Okinawa has already been destroyed by one war. And its residents know only too well that bases never protect civilians; they only make them more of a target.

These are dangerous days for the island. The governor—and the people of Okinawa—need all the support they can get.

Send postcards to:

Governor Hirokazu Nakaima
Secretariat Division,
Okinawa Prefecture,
Izumizaki,
Naha City,
Okinawa, Japan
900-8570

If you would like your postcard to be included on Dr. Kawamura’s wall of support, please take a snapshot before posting and send it to: http://postcardcampaignsavehenoko.blogspot.jp/.

Email: okinawaor@gmail.com.

Jon Mitchell is a Welsh-born writer based in Japan. In September 2012, Defoliated Island, a TV documentary based upon his research into the usage of Agent Orange on Okinawa, was awarded a commendation for excellence by Japan’s National Association of Commercial Broadcasters.