People who are not American citizens like me don’t have a vote in the U.S. elections, yet what happens at the center of the empire has an impact, positive or negative, on us.  So for us, analyzing what happened on November 3 and what its implications and consequences are is an urgent, necessary exercise.

This analysis is divided into three parts: what the far right did wrong, what progressives did right, and what are the challenges confronting U.S. progressives in the run-up to the 2028 presidential elections.

What the Far Right Did Wrong

Where did the far right go wrong? Here I found two books that I’ve just read particularly illuminating: David Ost’s Red Pill Politics and Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor’s End Times Fascism. One of the key points both books put forward is that the far right can’t rule via terror alone. It needs to have a positive program that brings economic and other benefits to their base and the groups they want to attract.

Even as they terrorized socialists, Jews, and Roma people, fascists in the early twentieth century in Germany and Italy offered social security measures, employment benefits, housing programs, massive construction projects, and leisure opportunities to their mass base of workers and middle-class people.

Trump over the last two years, in contrast, has ruled purely negatively, terrorizing migrants and people of color, raising tariffs to punitive levels, engaging in a senseless war. He didn’t offer any economic benefits to his white base, perhaps thinking that they would be content with the psychological satisfaction of seeing Immigration and Citizenship Enforcement (ICE) agents cruelly arrest and deport migrants and shooting anyone who resisted, even if they were white people.

But lack of a positive program for the white base was not the only thing that stymied the far right. There was just the total chaos of Trump’s reign—allowing Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu to enmesh him in an endless war with Iran after he had promised to be the “peace president,” denying that the United States had lost the war when it had clearly done so, denying the ravages of inflation on people’s pocketbooks. The far-right base does not mind the breaking of immigrants’ bones, but they cannot stand perpetual chaos and instability. That’s why many either crossed the political line and voted for the Democrats on November 3 or simply decided not to show up at the polls. The problem the American far right faces is that their chosen leader is a narcissist first and only a fascist second.

What Progressives Did Right

What did the progressives do right? Here I would highlight two things: the heroic resistance of ordinary people to ICE in Minnesota and the candidacy of Zohran Mamdani in New York City.

The impact of what happened in Minnesota in the early months of this year cannot be underestimated. The sight of masses of people coming together to protect their neighbors from being kidnapped by ICE agents invading their community provided inspiration not just to progressives but to ordinary decent people throughout the United States. If Americans did not want the authoritarian rule and cruelty the far right wanted to impose on the country, they had to go out to the streets to defend their rights.

Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor say it best:

In the snow and tear gas of Minnesota’s winter, the far right lost control over its central story about who is replacing whom and who is invading and who invaded…When thousands of masked and armed agents from out of town descended on an American city, that narrative could not hold. As residents witnessed strangers in tear gas and kidnap their parents, a profound moral revulsion set in.  Huge numbers of people many of whom had never protested before, knew something deep in their bones: they were literally being invaded by an outside force.  And they were bound and determined not to let their diverse and loving community be replaced by a police state.

Snowy Minneapolis was the turning point of the struggle against twenty-first century American fascism, much like freezing Stalingrad was the graveyard of the German Sixth Army during the Second World War.

The second key development that propelled the Democratic wave was Zohran Mamdani’s campaign for mayor of New York in 2025. Mamdani came up with what became the playbook for the 2026 elections during his campaign for mayor of New York City. There were three key elements: 1) don’t give too much credence to the polls, run and run hard, and the numbers will follow; 2) run an inclusive campaign, spreading hope and unity instead of sowing division and hate; and 3) run on affordability and don’t let the other side derail you with false issues, like accusing you of being anti-Semitic.

What began as a one-man campaign against the odds became at its end a massive collective effort. Again, Klein and Taylor say it best,

The campaign with its tens of thousands of volunteers making phone calls and knocking on doors [helped] New Yorkers to connect with another in ways many had not previously.  And while they found joy and community, they also came face-to-face with neighbors who were struggling. The people who made and delivered their food were being ripped off. The people who nursed them when they were sick and drove them in cabs and buses were barely scraping by, many families were at imminent risk of eviction.  he deepening realization—in a city overflowing with private wealth—made the threats of an ultrarich exodus less frightening than enraging.

The Mamdani playbook was successfully reproduced by Democratic candidates in state after state. In fact, it was adopted even beyond the borders of the US—for instance, in Berlin, where the progressive Die Linke party got the highest percentage of votes during the German regional elections last September.

Challenges to the Left

Let’s now turn to the challenges that confront progressives in the runup to the presidential elections of 2028.

For the left, the first challenge will be how to make sure that replacing their leadership will not result in intra-party bloodletting that will distract them from pushing their affordability programs. It’s fairly clear that Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Rep. Hakim Jeffries (D-NY) are not the people who can lead the Democrats at a time that people are expecting an aggressive approach to their multitude of problems, from dealing with racism and ending the attack on migrants to stopping inflation and bringing Trump to justice. Schumer and Jeffries are classic compromisers, and Trump will try to corner them into compromises that will blunt the fulfillment of the Democrats’ promises in the leadup to 2028 and allow the Republicans to regain lost ground.

So, the big challenge to the Democrats is how to avoid a debilitating internecine struggle and come up with the equivalent of a golden handshake that will allow Schumer and Jeffries to retire gracefully from the competition for leadership.

The second challenge is how to meet the very real promises of affordability that progressives ran on. Most pressing is how to bring inflation under control. There’s no way to do this except through controls on prices, and here they’ll come into conflict with the fundamental tenet of neoliberal ideology that you can’t interfere with the market. To solve the crisis of housing you can’t trust private developers, so government must manage either directly or indirectly the rapid construction of tens of millions of housing units. Government must move to decisively ban the construction of data centers and radically regulate AI, and this will bring progressives into sharp conflict with Silicon Valley and the billionaire class, as will taxes on the latter’s wealth.

In short, solving the affordability question necessarily moves the left closer to socialist solutions, so the Democratic Socialists of America and other progressives should expect full-blown resistance from the capitalist establishment and should be prepared for a full-scale ideological battle to win over the allegiance of the people. Even if the moderates do not want to frame it as a capitalism-versus-socialism battle, the conservatives and the far right will do so.

The third challenge is making Trump accountable for his multiple transgressions of the law. Clearly, the Democratic base wants this reckoning and will not allow him to go scot free. But it will not be easy to bring Trump to heel, since he fights best when cornered. Also, being a narcissist, he has a Samson complex: if he’s going down anyway, he’ll want to bring everything down with him.  So, Trump and the far right must not be underestimated since they’re most dangerous when they’ve suffered a massive defeat. You’ll need not just determination and courage but a smart strategy. And that’s one reason the struggle for the Democratic Party leadership is such a high-stakes battle.

A long-time observer of US politics, Walden Bello’s latest book is, Backlash: The Global Rise of the Radical Right, co-edited with Don Kalb (Pluto Press, 2026).  These observations were originally presented at a webinar sponsored by the Philippine socialist party PLM on Nov 14, 2026. He is a senior fellow at Foreign Policy In Focus.